Everton Toffee Recipe. The everton toffee company has been making small craft batches of butter toffee candy and butter toffee pretzels, each with the same rich, sweet aroma and artisan flavors that enchanted the village of everton and delighted the world centuries ago. Everton toffee butter toffee caramels, sea salt flavor (4 oz.
Dipped in decadent butter toffee, they taste unbelievably good. 30 pieces of sea salt butter toffee caramels and 20 butter toffee licorice. Who knew pretzels could be such an indulgence?